From real client conversations
Questions clients ask before hiring us
Real questions from brands we work with, paraphrased and answered the way we answered them. Names and details removed.
“Your case study shows a huge return. Will we see something like 8 to 10 times our investment within three or four months?”
A US heritage furniture brand asking about ROI before signing · Nov 2023
E
How we answered
We don't set numbers before we've seen how your own database responds, because the real value sits in your list. Like a good doctor, we diagnose first, using real data and insights, and then improve month on month. Even for our best-known case study, we never promised that result at the start. To be straightforward about timing: it usually takes at least three months to reach a positive ROI. The first month is about warming up and analysing the database, the second about improvements, and clearer results typically show from the third month onward.
“Before we give you access to our account, our team wants an NDA. How will you handle our customer data?”
A US industrial tooling manufacturer selling on WooCommerce and Klaviyo, planning a CRM migration · Oct 2026
E
How we answered
Asking for an NDA before sharing access is exactly the right step. We put the access terms in writing: read-only access through an analyst role, so we can't create, edit, send or delete anything; access limited to named people on our team with multi-factor authentication, and logins never shared; customer data stays in your platform, with no exports, API keys or third-party connections unless you approve them in writing; privacy commitments including notice within 72 hours of any security concern. You can remove our access at any time, and when the work ends we confirm in writing that it has stopped.
“If we start, what happens in the first month, and what results will you commit to?”
A US fine-jewelry brand with high-ticket pieces and a strict no-discount positioning · Sep 2026
E
How we answered
Here's what you can expect from day one: strategy by day three, the content calendar and first email design by day seven, campaigns live from week two, flow findings in week three, and a monthly report and strategy meeting at the end of each month. The monthly strategy decides which campaigns carry the brand story and which carry a release or a market moment, rather than deciding email by email. And we commit to the work, not to a number. Email results compound, so we'd rather show steady progress each month than promise something we haven't earned yet.
“Why didn't your original proposal cover all three payment situations from the start?”
A subscription film-streaming brand reviewing its automation scope · Sep 2026
E
How we answered
Because our audit looked for where the biggest impact would be, and at that stage only one scenario, failed renewals, had enough volume to justify a dedicated flow. Building all three upfront would have added cost without a proportional benefit. As consultants, our job is to recommend what's genuinely relevant and cost-effective for the business, not to maximize scope. When the client explained why the other two situations mattered to them, we discussed it openly, agreed an expanded plan and built the additional journeys. Scope can grow when the business case does.
“We're uneasy about giving an outside agency access to our CRM, domain and customer data. How do you protect it?”
A UK home-improvement services company onboarding with an email agency · Oct 2026
E
How we answered
It's a fair concern, and we'd rather address it formally than simply ask for trust. We offer a mutual NDA before access is granted, so confidentiality is in writing. We use account data, contacts and business information only to deliver the agreed scope, and we request only the access each task needs, such as domain settings for authentication or the CRM connection for syncing contacts. With over ten years of managing client accounts across marketing platforms, protecting client data is standard practice for us, not an exception.
“How much of our team's time will this take, and what do you need from us?”
An e-commerce brand with a small in-house marketing team · Aug 2025
E
How we answered
Very little beyond decisions. We handle execution end to end: strategy, copywriting, design and setup in the platform. Your team's role is timely approvals and product recommendations. We use a consistent, easy-to-review feedback format, aim to work two weeks ahead of the calendar, and absorb occasional short turnarounds internally without flagging urgency unless it's truly necessary. The one thing that matters is approval timing: if feedback stalls, campaigns get delayed or skipped, and gaps in communication with your audience can hurt engagement and deliverability. After the first calendar cycle we share a 45-day progress report.