Quick answer: most ecommerce stores need five jobs covered: an email and SMS platform, sign-up forms, reviews, loyalty, and (only for some stores) subscriptions and upsells. At October 2026 list prices, that core stack costs about $195 a month for a store doing $40K a month, $564 at $100K and $2,818 at $500K. The email platform is the biggest cost at every size, and the most common waste is paying for two tools that do the same job.
Key takeaways
- Start with the platform you already have. A switch has to save real money or earn more, because migrations cost time and carry deliverability risk.
- Pop-ups come free with most platforms. Klaviyo, Mailchimp and MailerLite all include sign-up forms, so a separate pop-up tool is rarely needed at the start.
- Check platform support before choosing a reviews app. Judge.me is now Shopify only, so BigCommerce and WooCommerce stores need something else.
- Loyalty and upsell tools need volume. They pay off once repeat orders are steady, not on day one.
- Overlap is the most common waste. In Excelohunt’s October 2026 check of 40 Melbourne online stores, 10 loaded two or more email or sign-up tools on the same homepage.
How Excelohunt Approaches Tools
Excelohunt does not push clients onto a favourite tool. Every engagement starts with an audit that lists what the store uses, what each tool costs and what it actually does, and the brand decides what to keep, add or drop. The goal is the lowest cost for the highest return, not the longest list of apps.
A real example: in November 2025 The Wig Outlet, a Brisbane store on BigCommerce, asked about Judge.me’s free plan for reviews. Excelohunt’s team checked the details before recommending anything. The free plan did not include review request emails or the BigCommerce integration, and Judge.me had announced it would end support for non-Shopify platforms. Its help centre confirms BigCommerce support ended on 12 January 2026. Recommending the free plan would have looked cheap and cost the store its reviews within weeks. You can read how email has performed for The Wig Outlet in its case study.
The Core Email Marketing Tech Stack
1. Email and SMS Platform
This is the centre of the stack: it holds your customer profiles, sends your campaigns and runs your automations. Excelohunt’s clients mostly use one of four platforms:
- Klaviyo for most Shopify stores, because of its ecommerce data, segmentation and built-in SMS.
- Mailchimp and MailerLite for smaller brands that want a lower monthly bill.
- GoHighLevel for business to business clients that also need a CRM and pipeline.
Here is what email costs on each at three list sizes (US list prices, checked 27 October 2026, billed monthly):
| Email profiles | Klaviyo | MailerLite (Comfort) | GoHighLevel (Starter + email usage) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10,000 | $150 | $89 | about $151 |
| 25,000 | $400 | $179 | about $232 |
| 100,000 | $1,380 | $439 | about $637 |
The GoHighLevel figures assume 8 emails per contact a month at its published $0.675 per 1,000 emails, plus the $97 Starter plan. Mailchimp’s Standard plan starts at $20 a month for up to 500 contacts; its larger tiers vary by region, so they are not listed here.
Klaviyo now bills SMS per message sent, with the rate depending on the country and the number type. Its calculator shows about $15 a month for 1,000 US texts, $70 for 5,000 and $240 for 20,000. For a deeper look, see Excelohunt’s Klaviyo pricing guide, its comparison of Klaviyo alternatives and its Klaviyo SMS guide.
2. Sign-Up Forms and Pop-Ups
Klaviyo includes web forms on its free and paid plans, and Mailchimp includes pop-up forms on all paid plans, so most stores do not need a separate pop-up tool. Stand-alone options such as Privy (from $24 a month for pop-ups) or Justuno (from $59 a month) make sense only when a store needs targeting the built-in forms cannot do.
What matters more than the tool is testing the offer and the timing. Two real results from Excelohunt’s clients:
- Crossfly, a premium menswear brand: a 20% welcome offer beat 10% on every measure over a 15 day test, and an 8 second delay beat 3 seconds on orders, revenue and average order value. See the Crossfly case study.
- The Wig Outlet: a 4 second delay beat 10 seconds by a small margin, and a plain 10% off converted 45.1% of new subscribers into buyers, against 30.7% for a spin the wheel game.
Excelohunt’s guide to Klaviyo forms and pop-ups covers the setup in detail.
3. Reviews
Reviews feed your emails with social proof and trigger review request flows after delivery. The main options, priced at October 2026:
| Tool | Starting price | Scales by | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Judge.me | Free, or $15 a month (Awesome) | Flat price | Shopify only since early 2026 |
| REVIEWS.io | Free, $19 or $45 a month (Shopify App Store) | Review invites | Crossfly uses REVIEWS.io |
| Okendo | $19 a month (up to 200 orders) | Monthly orders | $119 for 201 to 1,500 orders |
| Yotpo Reviews | Free up to 50 orders, then from $15 | Monthly orders | Pro plan from $119 |
| Klaviyo Reviews | Free up to 50 orders, then $25 | Monthly orders | Built into Klaviyo |
For Crossfly, Excelohunt places the REVIEWS.io review link in every market’s emails and runs a review request flow. The right choice depends on your store platform, your order volume and whether you need photo and video reviews.
4. Loyalty
A loyalty program gives your emails something to say beyond discounts: points balances, VIP tiers and rewards. October 2026 list prices:
| Tool | Starting price | Orders included |
|---|---|---|
| Smile.io | Free, $15 (Essential), $79 (Standard), $199 (Growth) | 200, 500, 1,000, 2,500 a month |
| LoyaltyLion | $199 (Classic) | 500 a month, up to $549 for 4,000 |
| Okendo Loyalty | $99 | Up to 200 a month |
| Appstle Loyalty | Free, $10, $30, $100 | 250, 500, 2,000, 5,000 a month |
A real example: for a wellness client, Excelohunt connected Judge.me and Appstle so that customers earn loyalty points for video reviews. Each review is approved by hand before points are awarded, so the program rewards real content rather than quick one line reviews.
5. Subscriptions and Upsells (Only If They Fit)
Subscription and upsell tools earn their cost only for stores that sell repeat products or have enough order volume:
- Appstle Subscriptions: free up to $500 a month of subscription revenue, then $10, $30 and $100 a month as revenue grows, with no transaction fees.
- Rebuy (cart and merchandising): from $45 a month at 500 orders, $89 at 1,000 and $425 at 5,000.
- Klaviyo Customer Hub: Excelohunt proposed it to Crossfly in May 2026 to turn the account page into a repeat purchase channel, with one click reordering, subscription management and personalised upsells.
What the Stack Costs by Store Size
These totals use published US list prices (checked 27 October 2026), monthly billing, a $100 average order and Klaviyo’s built-in forms. Your numbers will move with your order value and SMS volume.
| Store | SMS | Reviews | Loyalty | Core total | With subscriptions and upsells | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| About $40K a month (10,000 profiles, 400 orders, 1,000 texts) | $150 | $15 | $15 (Judge.me) | $15 (Smile.io) | $195 | $250 |
| About $100K a month (25,000 profiles, 1,000 orders, 5,000 texts) | $400 | $70 | $15 (Judge.me) | $79 (Smile.io) | $564 | $683 |
| About $500K a month (100,000 profiles, 5,000 orders, 20,000 texts) | $1,380 | $240 | $499 (Okendo) | $699 (Smile.io plus extra orders) | $2,818 | $3,343 |
There is usually a cheaper version. At $40K a month, Judge.me’s free plan and Appstle Loyalty bring the core stack to about $175. At $100K, the same swap brings it to about $500. At $500K, Judge.me Awesome and Appstle Loyalty bring it to about $1,735. Whether the cheaper version is right depends on the features you actually use, which is what an audit checks.
How to Wire It All Together
A stack only earns its cost when the tools talk to each other. The essentials:
- Store to email platform: orders, products, carts and browsing events must flow into the email platform, or flows like abandoned cart and post purchase cannot run.
- Reviews and loyalty into email: review submissions, points balances and VIP tiers should arrive as profile properties or events, so emails can mention them.
- One sign-up tool: pick one form tool and remove the others, or subscribers get duplicate pop-ups and data splits across systems.
- Authenticate your sending domain: SPF, DKIM and DMARC. In Excelohunt’s report on 25 ecommerce email audits, 6 stores had domain authentication missing or failing. In its check of 40 Melbourne online stores, 31 were not enforcing DMARC.
- Check attribution settings: a wrong attribution window can hide most of what email earns, as the fragrance retailer case study shows.
Excelohunt’s guide to ecommerce integrations that drive revenue goes deeper on the data flow, and its email deliverability guide covers authentication.
Common Tech Stack Mistakes
- Two tools doing one job. Two email or pop-up tools on one site is common: 10 of the 40 Melbourne stores in Excelohunt’s check loaded two or more.
- Paying for features nobody uses. A premium reviews or loyalty plan on a store with a few hundred orders a month rarely pays back.
- Choosing a tool before checking platform support, as the Judge.me change for BigCommerce stores showed.
- Switching platforms to fix a strategy problem. In Excelohunt’s audits the leak is usually segmentation, list health or missing flows, not the tool. 22 of the 25 audited stores sent campaigns without any engagement segment.
Review Your Stack Every Quarter
Once a quarter, list every tool, its monthly cost and what it earned or enabled, and remove anything that overlaps or goes unused. Check that integrations still pass data after app updates, and that your domain authentication still passes. A once a year review should also compare your platform’s price at your current list size with the alternatives.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the minimum email marketing tech stack for an online store?
An email and SMS platform with built-in sign-up forms, plus a reviews app. Loyalty, subscriptions and upsell tools only earn their cost once a store has enough repeat orders. For a store doing about $40K a month, that core stack costs roughly $195 a month at October 2026 list prices.
How much does an ecommerce email tech stack cost per month?
At October 2026 list prices and a $100 average order, a core stack costs about $195 a month at $40K of monthly revenue, $564 at $100K and $2,818 at $500K. The email platform is the biggest line at every size.
Should we switch email platforms?
Only if the numbers say so. Excelohunt compares the options in an audit, including cost and what the store actually uses, and the brand decides. A switch costs time and carries deliverability risk, so it has to save real money or earn more.
Does Judge.me still work on BigCommerce or WooCommerce?
No. Judge.me’s help centre says it ended support for WooCommerce, Square and Squarespace in late 2025, Duda on 31 December 2025, BigCommerce on 12 January 2026 and PrestaShop on 31 January 2026. It remains fully supported on Shopify.
Related Guides
- Klaviyo pricing in 2026, by list size
- Best Klaviyo alternatives in 2026
- Klaviyo agency pricing: what a Klaviyo expert costs
- Klaviyo forms and pop-ups that convert
- What Excelohunt found in 25 ecommerce email audits
Prices are US list prices taken from each vendor’s own pricing page, help centre or Shopify App Store listing on 27 October 2026. Vendors change prices often, so check before you buy. All trademarks belong to their owners, and Excelohunt is not endorsed by the companies named here.
Not sure what your stack should look like? Get a free email audit. Excelohunt will list every tool you pay for, what each one earns, and what you could drop or add.